Critical Report
Children’s Book Design Critical Report
About the E-book
The eBook that I
have designed takes a focus on the World War Two era, which covers topics on
two ends of the reality of the war. Two spreads take on a topic related to the
evacuation of children from cities and how they were able to contribute to the
war away from the frontlines while living new lives in the countryside. The
third and last spread is based on how Britain fought the World War against
Germany, and understanding the decisions made by the military forces as well as
the benefits and consequences that come from those actions made during the war.
Research
& Background
When designing a
layout for an e-book, I had to consider and account for the information
provided for the topics at hand. There are many details about World War Two. In
my findings and research, there were many journal entries from evacuees talking
about their experiences in the countryside during the war. In the topic of
fighting the war, I chose to include the “V” rocket project which covered the
scenario of planning a sabotage operation for the military. A challenge was
coming up with a format that would be informative enough to give learners some
insight about the time period, but not so much that younger learners would lose
interest at the sight of excessively large blocks of text.
CGP Books, a company that produces educational books aimed at
children in key stages 2, 3 and 4, are very well received for their content by
a number of exam boards and school teachers. Most commonly, their spreads
explaining various subjects use a lot of prose and split onto small chunks of
text. This is also combined with various illustrations for the audience to look
at to give some sense of what they are reading. Often, very simplified and
straightforward characters are the most effective with keeping audiences
engaged by directing their attention to the information. Other characters like Pusheen,
and those in books like Horrible Histories also are strong examples that are
used to communicate with their audiences, as they provide an interaction with
the topic or heading.
Designs,
Process & Production
For the first
two spreads I thought of constructing and using activities that involved
identifying the surroundings, atmosphere and the different jobs that children
took during their time in the country to contribute to the war effort, which
should provide some insight on children’s lives during times of conflict.
Having learners analyse letters and images about the countryside will develop
their observational skills, and encourage them to suggest whether or not it was
a nice place to live. The third spread is more based on the warfare aspect of the
war. With the use of a map[8], a team discussion activity will be
used, where learners would be stepping into a commander’s shoes where they will
be discussing the best plan of attack to slow Germany’s attack on Britain. A
target map of Peenemunde is included in the spread to be used in a team
discussion. The team building exercise intends to build on their ability to
understand the situation and realise the outcomes and consequences of the
actions made to win the war, as well as encourage learners to consider the
various “what if?” situations concerning the alternatives to the real outcome
of the event.
Considering the amount of detail given
in the documents provided by the National Archives, the clearly immediate
problem was including a bulk of text into the e-book. Experimenting with text
boxes made it pretty clear that children would not be interested in this amount
of pure text. In fact, condensing the information down into smaller boxes
wasn’t quite enough. Early stages of my design involved shortening information
to a minimum to account for the assumed reading levels of Key Stage 2 learners,
and separating other interesting facts away from the main body so that they
wouldn’t distract from the learning main experience. When statistics or
additional details are provided, I felt like they should be included in a
separate box (seen in the final document in the “Did You Know?” section) for
further reading, so as to not drag on the reading of the main content for too
long, which could risk failing to keep the consumer’s attention. Some of the
terminology couldn’t be removed due to being important technical terms, so the
addition of a section explaining the term was also included to give a short
education on what it is.
I
also created illustrations for each of the spreads to make the content a little
more interesting and interactive. Characters in a cartoonish style were used
and implemented as a banner that ran across the top of the first half of the
spread to introduce new learners to the topics as well as adding a
distinguishing feature for each of the topics. Having a visual element to look
at should engage learners with the content provided. The intended function of
the speaking characters is to provide some context to the topic, and leading
the reader’s focus throughout the spread.
Final
finishes to the document include colouring the images with a simplistic colour
scheme which is enough to catch the reader’s attention, and adding an old paper
texture as a background to each of the spreads to keep old timey feel of the
World War 2 theme.
Conclusion
The
final product contains a range of content based on the Second World War for key
stages 2 and 3 learners to engage with, exploring a few situations and
interpreting sources in several ways. Illustrated characters appear on the
spreads to kick-start the topic and provide some context for the reading and
activities. I think this is particularly effective to grasp the reader’s
initial attention, as the characters serve as the starting point for the
document, which follows onto the main body of the text that educates the
learners on the topic in question, with additional interesting facts separate
to the main content. Visually, this organises the information well, however, I
still question whether or not the core content of each spread appears
overwhelming. The definite upside is that the information is as concise as it
can be, using clear and simplified vocabulary that is suited for learners in key
stages 2 and 3 without omitting the terminologies entirely. The general layout
of each leftmost side of the spreads are similar, which is a possible factor
that I could have changed for each spread. Using the same design layout can be
picked up on, and become a bit of a bore to read over and over. Having said
that, it is outweighed by the use of different illustrations, which have the
potential of being a signature image for each of the topics that the readers
will engage with and recognise. Some design elements could be added to improve
the visual interests on the activity pages on spreads 2 and 3, but overall, the
material is presented neatly with a good number of illustrated elements
accompanying it.
Some improvements I would consider is creating a
hand rendered font to use for each of the spread titles, and possibly doing
some more colour corrections on my illustrations because, in print, the colours
appear rather dark after having digitally rendered them using digital art
applications. With a little bit more time on the illustrations, the banners for
each of the spreads could have also had a more detailed background to make the
visual elements more interesting.
Comments
Post a Comment